“This is one of the greatest meltdowns that I’ve ever seen in 40 years,” Rodriguez said as the Yankees failed to become the first team down 3-0 in the World Series to force a Game 6. Judge told reporters that the fly ball might’ve been the difference in the game, but didn’t say why he dropped the ball.

To commemorate the World Series’ return to the Bronx, the Yankees are turning to one of the franchise’s top October heroes: Derek Jeter.